Discussion about this post

User's avatar
SUE Speaks's avatar

What are you doing to help us move along, singing a song, side by side?

Expand full comment
Bill Miller's avatar

Suzanne, do you have any theories about why, despite 30 years-worth of awareness about the problems (Rachel Carson/“Silent Spring”, Donella Meadows/“Limits to Growth”, Brian Swimme, Thomas Berry, Earth Day, etc.), we continue down the path toward destruction? I suppose an obvious factor is an economic system that values profits over people. Yet I suspect there is an underlying cause from which even that ethic emerges.

In a coffeeshop conversation in Munich Germany years ago, a patron remarked that: “You know, America was largely formed out of the criminals and outcasts of European society.” That may be an overstatement, but I think it points to the basis of the uniquely American emphasis on the ethic of rugged individualism, achievement, and self-actualization. This is a stance under which we are each competing as lone actors to “pull ourselves up by our own bootstraps”, “make something of ourselves”, “get ahead” (implying others are left behind) — all under the myth that “it’s a level playing field” in which, by hard work and dedication, “anyone can make it”.

Even if flawed, that model did work well enough to build 20th Century America. Yet in a subtle way, it opposes any sense of true community and a mutually shared fate. We must always be wary of the motives of others — even friends and family. Rather than true community, others naturally fall into the role of allies or opponents in an individual quest for self-actualization and aggrandizement. (Hence Margaret Thatcher’s famous remark: “There is no society.”)

Even in the above context, governments are required since societal needs like national infrastructure, defense, basic research, international relations are too large to be handled by individuals or even corporate entities.

Moreover, today’s existential problems like climate change, war, nuclear threat, and environmental destruction really require a sense of globally shared fate and collective action. Continuing under the ethic of competition for relative advantage over others posed as opponents and enemies, will almost certainly ensure the demise of this current iteration of human civilization.

Can we evolve? Can we recognize and embrace our interdependence? Or do we repeat the fate of extinct past empires? It’s probably time to make a choice.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts